The Blog Roll

Subscribe

Titles RSS

Get Posts by Email

Powered By Powerblogs
Art Trivializes Life

Yale Art major Aliza Shvarts '08 wants to make a statement.

Beginning next Tuesday, Shvarts will be displaying her senior art project, a documentation of a nine-month process during which she artificially inseminated herself "as often as possible" while periodically taking abortifacient drugs to induce miscarriages. Her exhibition will feature video recordings of these forced miscarriages as well as preserved collections of the blood from the process.

The artist said, "I hope it inspires some sort of discourse," Shvarts said. "Sure, some people will be upset with the message and will not agree with it, but it's not the intention of the piece to scandalize anyone."

Good thing she said that because we wouldn't want to mistake her intent. Trivialize surely but not scandalize. Oh, no, we wouldn't want to mistake her message. BTW, I love how they said "forced miscarriages". What's wrong? Are we having trouble saying ABORTIONS? Does it sound nicer to call it "forced miscarriages"? Yeah, probably but I'm not falling for it. There is nothing "nice" about this "art" project.

It's disgusting, disturbing and does nothing to advance the argument that women have abortions because they "need them" and they don't do them lightly. They wouldn't have abortions for trivial reasons like birth control or FUCKING ART PROJECTS.

No, clearly, this woman had "health issues".

Posted by Rosemary on 04.17.2008
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
She's just poking at the righties. Probably used ketchup.
4.17.2008 2:23pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
Sounds like she hit Rose's hot button, too.
4.17.2008 2:27pm
Rosemary, Queen of All Evil (mail):
ISSUE POST

And yes, she hit my button!
4.17.2008 2:30pm
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
She gotcha. Heh heh.
4.17.2008 2:47pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
This is an issue post?

Sounds more like a molehill post.

What's the issue?
4.17.2008 2:55pm
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
What's the issue?

That people doing something to get right-wingers enraged is enraging right-wingers.
4.17.2008 2:56pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
And that's not fair!!

P.S. great answer.
4.17.2008 3:00pm
TQL:
I am very pro-choice and I think this is just disgusting and wrong on sooooo many levels.
...but then, when you have a movement that refuses to even address life issues in the issue of abortion this is what happens, I suppose.
4.17.2008 3:28pm
IB Bill (mail) (www):
What's the issue?

Discourse on art and the human body, or a discussion of the inherent value of human life, or hoaxes in a mass-media age. Something like that.
4.17.2008 3:36pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
Is there an epidemic of, you know, disgusting art exhibits of this type? Seems to me if you don't want to see this, you avoid the gallery, or something.

Am I missing something here?
4.17.2008 4:33pm
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
I pledge to you all that I will not attend this exhibit because I find the subject matter ghoulish and pretty pointless.
4.17.2008 4:37pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
I don't plan on seeing it either. Last thing I'd want to witness.

Who goes to these things anyway -- besides the reporters who get the press release?
4.17.2008 5:02pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
The smaller the molehill, the bigger the mountain Rose makes out of it.
4.17.2008 5:02pm
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
Who goes to these things anyway -- besides the reporters who get the press release?

People who hear about it from irate bloggers?
4.17.2008 5:24pm
maryatexitzero (mail) (www):
This art major sounds like she has some very serious mental problems. Unfortunately, a lot of symptoms of mental disease show up during the college years. Since the university is supposed to act 'in loco parentis', they should should be spending less time on the political and 'moral' issues, and more time getting her some help.

Otherwise, I wish people would stop classifying neurotic, theatrical showboating as 'art'. Art is the use of a real skill used to produce some kind of aesthetic result. Calling excretory displays of mental illness 'art' makes the whole term worthless.
4.17.2008 6:18pm
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
Otherwise, I wish people would stop classifying neurotic, theatrical showboating as 'art'.

Well, there goes Andrew Lloyd Webber...
4.17.2008 6:29pm
maryatexitzero (mail) (www):
Yup..
4.17.2008 6:40pm
McKiernan:
First thing to do is check out how many turkey basters this woman has in her kitchen. Like will she fortunately run out of them any time soon ?

Next stop would be an interview with Dr. Phil Oprah, then Larry King, then Dr. Phil.
4.17.2008 6:50pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Lemme get this straight. The nazi-hating, channels her holocaust surviving relatives at every opportunity, nice lady blogger who defends stamping a swastika on her side-banner as "Free Speach, Baby!" is having a bit of trouble shrugging off someone else whose deliberately offensive and over-the-top politically inspired public display is not just uncalled for, but supporting a cause she doesn't approve of.

Is that about right?

How about a slide-show of cattle-branding abortion doctors with swastikas on their winkie-covered asses and calling that "art." That okay, Rose?
4.17.2008 7:39pm
McKiernan:
Mark,

Do you ever get past your own ego long enough to actually say something ?
4.17.2008 8:45pm
Rosemary, Queen of All Evil (mail):
How about a slide-show of cattle-branding abortion doctors with swastikas on their winkie-covered asses and calling that "art." That okay, Rose?

Sure, that's fine.

Oh and I don't have to channel my holocaust surviving relative ... I live with her. And if I actually typed what she wanted me to type in response - you'd still be blushing. She didn't get your "humor" but I explained that you were trying to teach me a lesson. Keep at it...you play angry nutty liberal with such flair!
4.17.2008 9:03pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Nice to be appreciated in my own time.
4.17.2008 9:22pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
Oh and I don't have to channel my holocaust surviving relative ... I live with her.

Your mother is a Holocaust survivor? Which death camp was she in?
4.17.2008 9:28pm
Rosemary, Queen of All Evil (mail):
Email me and I'll tell you. That's as far as I go in public with her private life.
4.17.2008 9:30pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
McK:

Uh ... yep.

But true learning comes from good questioning, which is why the art of cross-examination is the high point of so much dramatic television.

The wisdom comes from asking, and asking well. The trick is to know what to ask.

Your question, however, ... well, keep trying.
4.17.2008 9:30pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Your mother is a Holocaust survivor? Which death camp was she in?

They missed?

McK:

Uh, yep ... I say stuff.

But true wisdom comes from good questioning, which is why the art of cross-examination is the high-point of so much television drama.

Only the wisest ask the best questions, getting wiser still. The trick is knowing what to ask, knowing that the act of questioning itself is revealing.

Your question, however ... well, keep trying.

My question of you, therefore, is do you think I'm egotistical because you think I think I'm wise, or is my wisdom revealed by saying things in such a way you cannot comprehend due to your lack of wisdom as revealed by your question?

If your initial instinct is to answer, "huh?" you are on the road to enlightenment, but you're not a grasshopper yet.
4.17.2008 9:42pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
I however am not wise enough to figure out why the gremlins on Rose's server insist on fucking with me and double-posted half my post.
4.17.2008 9:44pm
matoko_chan (mail):
erm...it wuz a hoax.
4.17.2008 10:35pm
matoko_chan (mail):
it was performance art....she was harvesting reactions.
;)


so guillable u ares
4.17.2008 10:36pm
matoko_chan (mail):
i totally dont get that frenzied response to using abortifacts on non-sentient cell clumps anyways.
its whack.
prospective olympians used blood-doping for years and years.

its like Che.
rightside ppl get ever so worked up about Che, but to my gen he's just a cool t-shirt.
;)
4.17.2008 10:42pm
McKiernan:
josan,

ur ona roll,
bt he hu is,
somtim, lft,
erst still,
wacki ego,
kissme.
4.17.2008 10:59pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Ah, but McK,

Zee Beggaahr who sit in marketplace, izz deaf to song of mocking bird.
4.17.2008 11:04pm
McKiernan:
Mark,

Somebody needs to tell Howard Dean to go fuck off.

You're delegated as senior leftist around here.

Left ?
4.17.2008 11:59pm
shep (mail):
"i totally dont get that frenzied response to using abortifacts on non-sentient cell clumps anyways.
its whack."


fru, not lik she cut off an ear r sumpin.

(Just trying to return the favor)
4.18.2008 1:22am
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
But I hate doctors, McK. They all the time trying to stick me with stuff and taste my pee. They're yucky. Have Ara talk to Howie.

Hey, Wa happ'd to that really cool crooked cross thingy Rose had on her side bar. Now she's got sum stuff looks like a dummy lawyer wrote.

Hmmm
4.18.2008 2:46am
Ara Rubyan (www):
Well, I'm glad to see the swastika is gone from Rose's sidbar.

Good for you Rose. A bit late, but better than never.

How much were they paying you for that ad anyway?
4.18.2008 4:41am
Rosemary, Queen of All Evil (mail):
How much were they paying you for that ad anyway?

More than I'm getting for child support...
4.18.2008 9:26am
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Every nickel counts.
4.18.2008 9:55am
Ara Rubyan (www):
Every nickel counts.

Yeah, I suppose, although there isn't enough money in the world that would be worth putting a swastika on my front page.
4.18.2008 10:09am
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
So Rose, did you finally figure out that you and the folks like you that got so up-in-arms were all part of the performance, that your reaction was a necessary ingredient of the hoax?
4.18.2008 1:56pm
Jonno:
Nice that manipulating people to get a good grade is now accepted behavior. If that's modern education, then DO NOT WANT.
4.18.2008 4:23pm
double-plus-ungood (mail) (www):
Nice that manipulating people to get a good grade is now accepted behavior.

Manipulating SOME people. Others identified it as fake immediately.
4.18.2008 5:53pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
If that's modern education, then DO NOT WANT.

You might need.
4.18.2008 6:21pm
Brian Macker (mail) (www):
It'll be funny if she was a "righty" exposing the utter depravity of her professors for approving such a project. It mocks art more than "righties".

In fact, if you read the article you'd see that the "lefties" (if you think that way) were outraged as well.

Did you miss this part:


Few people outside of Yale's undergraduate art department have heard about Shvarts' exhibition. Members of two campus abortion-activist groups — Choose Life at Yale, a pro-life group, and the Reproductive Rights Action League of Yale, a pro-choice group — said they were not previously aware of Schvarts' project.

Alice Buttrick '10, an officer of RALY, said the group was in no way involved with the art exhibition and had no official opinion on the matter.

Sara Rahman '09 said, in her opinion, Shvarts is abusing her constitutional right to do what she chooses with her body.

"[Shvarts' exhibit] turns what is a serious decision for women into an absurdism," Rahman said. "It discounts the gravity of the situation that is abortion."

CLAY member Jonathan Serrato '09 said he does not think CLAY has an official response to Schvarts' exhibition. But personally, Serrato said he found the concept of the senior art project "surprising" and unethical.

"I feel that she's manipulating life for the benefit of her art, and I definitely don't support it," Serrato said. "I think it's morally wrong."


Any reasonable person thinks this way. I'm sure if her project involved needlessly splattering pheasant against bumper tied canvases at 80 mph then not only PETA but hunters would be upset about it.
4.18.2008 6:28pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Oh BTW. Well done DPU, good eye.
4.18.2008 8:32pm
Brian Macker (mail) (www):
"They missed?"

Oh, BTW. Extremely offensive, Mark, bad form. Extremely bad form.
4.18.2008 8:37pm
Brian Macker (mail) (www):
I take that back the abortion group apparently wasn't sharp enough to realize it was unethical.
4.18.2008 8:38pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
Bad Form? Hell Brian, I thought it was downright despicable myself.
4.18.2008 11:27pm
Brian Macker (mail) (www):
Was that what you were aiming at and are you disappointed at me not giving you full credit?
4.19.2008 2:16pm
Mark Adams, who's always correct, get used to it. (mail) (www):
I'd catch you up on the vast puppeteer conspiracy, but then I'd have confiscate everything in your sock drawer.
4.19.2008 2:34pm
matoko_chan (mail):
well..ben stein is manipulating people.
is that ok?

was the abortion hoax really IQ-baiting?

Its Science and Academe vs the religious right, ben stein, the sandwichboard guys and the patriarchial daddies of the FLDS.

i know which side i'm on.
4.19.2008 3:02pm
matoko_chan (mail):
maybe it is SES-baiting.
Socio-Economic Status.

or education-differential baiting?
man, that's awkward.
a little help guyz?
4.19.2008 3:05pm
shep (mail):
Obviously a new meaning for "red-baiting". (Sorry.)
4.19.2008 8:13pm
Ara Rubyan (www):
or education-differential baiting?
man, that's awkward.
a little help guyz?


A "stupid tax," like the lottery which is a tax on people who can't do math.
4.20.2008 7:35am
Account:
Password:
Remember info?

Help Feed the Children

Tip Jar

Amazon Wish List

QOAE's Amazon Wishes

The images in the advertisements below are dynamically placed and do not necessarily reflect the views of the QoAE.net.

R.I.P. Steven Malcolm Anderson

flag_half_mast.gif

November 27, 2005



QOAE's Favorite article or person

Most Recent Articles

Who Is The

Email Policy

© 2004 Rosemary Esmay & QOAE.net
© 2004 Alice Kondraciuk, web design